Los Angeles: Five episodes into With Love, Meghan, audiences will have learned three things about host Meghan Markle: she takes pride in making breakfast for her family every morning; her favourite tunes are ’70s soft rock, Yacht rock and French dinner party music; and she no longer wishes to be referred to as Meghan Markle.
“It’s so funny that you keep saying ‘Meghan Markle,’ you know, I’m Sussex now,” the Duchess of Sussex tells guest Mindy Kaling in episode two of the Netflix series. “You have kids and you go, ‘No, I share my name with my children.’ I didn’t know how meaningful it would be to me, but it just means so much to go, ‘This is our little family name.'”
Picture-Perfect Montecito
Described on Netflix’s Tudum platform as “a heartfelt tribute to the beauty of Southern California,” With Love, Meghan lives up to its name with picturesque views of the mountains from the backyard of Meghan and Prince Harry’s Montecito home, some 80 miles north of Los Angeles. There she shares a homemade buttercream cake with longtime friend and makeup artist Daniel Martin in episode one, picks goldenberries from a lush home garden for a rainbow-themed charcuterie board, harvests honey for beeswax candle-making, and prepares meals for her guests — single-skillet spaghetti among them.
The dish is perhaps the most relatable aspect of the eight-episode series, which is arguably too perfectly shot for its own good. Meghan doesn’t so much as get a spattering of egg batter on her Zara pants, Loro Piana top or Jenni Kayne cardigan when she arrives early to bake a fresh frittata for Kaling — much less share aspects of her personality beyond having a bright green thumb and a passion for home-cooked meals and hospitality.
Where It Falls Short
It’s in that regard that the show doesn’t live up to its promise of a reimagined lifestyle programme or “candid conversation with friends, new and old.” The closest the series comes is L.A. chef Roy Choi explaining the racism underlying MSG’s negative reputation as they prepare Korean fried chicken and champagne in episode three. Otherwise, the show comes across as an oddly timed peek into how the other half lives.
With Love, Meghan was criticised as out of touch from the moment its trailer dropped on January 2. Ten days later, Meghan pushed the original January 15 premiere to March 4 due to the Los Angeles wildfires. But with an economy many believe is on the brink of recession, and a sociopolitical environment in which the demographic most likely to connect with the show’s tradwife aesthetic is equally likely to resent Meghan for her racial identity and for calling out the poor treatment she has received, it’s hard to see the lifestyle programme as relevant to anyone except Meghan and Harry — who inked a five-year deal with Netflix worth a reported $100 million in 2020.
A representative for Netflix told Vanity Fair in its February cover story “American Hustle,” which heavily critiqued the couple’s bumpy transition from British to Hollywood royalty: “We don’t disclose our financial deals with talent, but I can confirm to you on the record that the $100M figure is not correct.”
The Naivete Question
For all its attempts at “practical how-tos,” it’s hard to discredit a nugget that producer Jane Marie — who worked with the couple as they developed audio projects at Archewell — told Vanity Fair: “They have this naivete and their hopefulness about what’s possible in terms of storytelling and good works and all those things.”
Immediately upon the show’s March 4 debut, criticism roared in from both American and British press, categorising the series as “an ego trip not worth taking” and an “exercise in narcissism.” Long-standing assessments of the former Suits star likely underscored Meghan’s reticence to share more of herself with her audience. To an already leery viewer, that lack of openness and vulnerability doesn’t help.
The Missing Ingredient
While it’s unfair to ask Meghan to apologise for her wealth or the world she and her friends inhabit, the attempts at being aspirational — like remarking how sweet it is to build a balloon arch by hand for her kids’ parties rather than hire someone — fall flat when there’s no honest conversation about the difficulties of motherhood with fellow mom guests. That element would better ground the series than the overuse of edible flower sprinkles.
Media and public scrutiny of Meghan has been lengthy and unwarranted since she first became romantically tied to Prince Harry in 2016. Unfortunately, unlike her 2022 Archetypes podcast — which gave listeners a greater understanding of who she and her guests were outside their personas — With Love, Meghan, no doubt in its attempt to protect its host from greater critique, presents her as nothing more than a stereotype of a perfect wife and mother.
Without the ingredient of relatability, which audiences crave more than anything, the series doesn’t serve up much more than fancy recipes that, according to the latest data on the price of eggs, most viewers can’t afford to make anyway.