‘John Doe’ Review: Loaded Dramatic Ideas Fight for Survival in a Mid Thriller

Bolsterflip By Bolsterflip
5 Min Read

Chennai: Director-writer Madhumita’s second release this month (after Love Always) is a far more sophisticated film, broaching topics often deemed too tough for our movies to discuss.

Despite the hard exterior of an investigative thriller, it’s the dramatic moments that reveal the writer’s sensitivity.

The Mortuary Scene

This is most evident in a scene where a broken father is called into a mortuary to identify a corpse. Rather than rushing through it for the sake of the larger plot, the film slows down and gives this parent the dignity he deserves. He’s nervous, confused, and hoping against hope in these brief moments.

The film is just as invested in the police officer hero, for whom it is impossible to treat such an event as merely part of the job — he vomits when he reaches a crime scene early on.

The scene deserved a stronger actor to capture the father’s full emotions, but you see the difference when the camera turns to Arjun Das’ Chandru.

An Antithesis of the Usual Cop Hero

His is a performance worth discussing separately, because he’s the antithesis of the police officer hero we usually see in our movies.

He’s the son of a police officer, but he clearly takes after his more sensitive, caring mother. In an interrogation scene, he doesn’t arm-twist or beat the bad guy into submission, choosing instead to get there with patience and consideration. Instead of perpetuating male chauvinism, here’s a police officer who appears to be its victim.

The Buddy-Cop Dynamic

This dichotomy goes a long way in Chandru’s interactions with fellow officer A. Rao (Sanchana Natarajan). Despite the weight of everything going on, the movie briefly develops enjoyably into the dynamics of a fun buddy-cop film.

Just when you feel Chandru’s methods are too pacifist to deal with the mess they’re in, Rao steps in, kicks butt and gets what she wants.

Where Drama Supersedes Thriller

The thriller aspect comes with the case of children who go missing in similar fashion. The film reveals just enough about the case for us to understand its seriousness without making it the only focus.

Here again, the dramatic moments supersede the thriller. When Rao is deputed to confront a particularly troubled teenager, the topics range from sibling rivalry to childhood trauma, jealousy to deep-rooted self-loathing. We know exactly how the scene will end and what information it will reveal, but the motivations feel so refreshing that you feel more interested in the whys and not so much the hows.

What Draws You Out

What draws you out at regular intervals is how the film tries to be bilingual. A large portion is set in the TN-Kerala border, and you understand the logical reason for this mix in dialogue. But clubbed with sync sound, you struggle to make sense of what certain actors are saying — especially when it becomes clear they’re speaking an alien tongue.

The choice of actors playing smaller characters also works overtime to take you away from the natural flow.

The Convenience Problem

But what feels most grating is the way the film lacks imagination in how it reveals valuable details about the case.

In one instance, a character explains, in so many words, how she happened to see a creep disposing of a hard disk after spotting him walking seedily into a neighbour’s house. It’s the kind of detail that changes the course of the film, but instead of showing it in an interesting manner, the film relies far too heavily on one convenient monologue.

The same can be said about how easy it feels to get to the film’s most important criminal. All it takes is a tiny nudge to set up a massive 20-minute information dump to reveal all of their motivations, modus operandi and even dietary preferences.

The Verdict

What you’d enjoyed so much in the earlier parts suddenly begins to go missing, and a clever drama about bad parenting gets lost in a middling thriller about the most generic of twists.

Share This Article
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *